Question 1

What's the difference between aggregate and failure reports?

Accepted Answer

Aggregate reports provide daily summaries of authentication results, while failure reports contain detailed information about individual authentication failures. Aggregate reports are essential for monitoring, while failure reports help with troubleshooting specific issues.

Question 2

Should I use the same email for both report types?

Accepted Answer

It's recommended to use different email addresses for aggregate and failure reports. Aggregate reports are high-volume daily summaries, while failure reports are detailed and less frequent. Separate mailboxes help with organization and filtering.

Question 3

How long should I monitor with p=none before enforcing?

Accepted Answer

Monitor with p=none for at least one week, but preferably 2-4 weeks for larger organizations. This ensures you capture all email patterns including weekly/monthly campaigns and different business cycles.

Question 4

Can I skip the quarantine phase and go directly to reject?

Accepted Answer

While technically possible, it's not recommended. The quarantine phase allows recipients to review potentially legitimate emails that failed authentication. Skipping to reject means these emails are permanently lost.

Question 5

What percentage should I start with for gradual rollout?

Accepted Answer

Start with 5-10% for small organizations or 1-5% for large organizations. The key is to start small and increase gradually while monitoring for any issues with legitimate email delivery.

Question 6

Do I need separate DMARC records for subdomains?

Accepted Answer

Not necessarily. Subdomains inherit the organizational domain's DMARC policy unless they have their own record. Only create subdomain-specific records if you need different policies for different subdomains.

Question 7

What if my DNS provider doesn't support DMARC records?

Accepted Answer

DMARC records are standard DNS TXT records. Any DNS provider that supports TXT records can host DMARC records. The hostname should be _dmarc.yourdomain.com and the value should be your DMARC policy string.

Question 8

How do I know if my DMARC record is working?

Accepted Answer

Use our DMARC checker tool to verify the record is published correctly. Then monitor your DMARC reports to see authentication results. You should start receiving aggregate reports within 24-48 hours of publication.

Question 9

Can I change my DMARC policy after implementation?

Accepted Answer

Yes, DMARC policies can be updated anytime by modifying the DNS TXT record. Changes typically take effect within 24-48 hours depending on TTL settings. Always monitor reports after making changes.

Question 10

What happens if I don't receive DMARC reports?

Accepted Answer

If you're not receiving reports, check that your DMARC record is published correctly, the email addresses are valid and accessible, and your email server can receive reports from various sources. Some receivers may not send reports immediately.

Question 11

What is DMARC alignment and why does it matter?

Accepted Answer

DMARC alignment ensures that the domain in the From header matches the domain used in SPF or DKIM authentication. Strict alignment (default) requires exact domain matches, while relaxed alignment allows subdomains. Proper alignment is crucial for DMARC authentication to pass.

Question 12

How do I handle third-party email services like MailChimp or SendGrid?

Accepted Answer

Third-party services need proper SPF includes and DKIM signing with your domain. Most services provide specific SPF mechanisms to include and can set up DKIM with your domain. Ensure these are configured before implementing DMARC enforcement.

Question 13

What's the difference between SPF, DKIM, and DMARC?

Accepted Answer

SPF validates sending IP addresses, DKIM validates message integrity with cryptographic signatures, and DMARC ties them together with alignment requirements and provides reporting. All three work together to prevent email spoofing and phishing.

Question 14

Can DMARC break legitimate email delivery?

Accepted Answer

Yes, if implemented incorrectly. Common causes include missing SPF records for legitimate senders, improper DKIM configuration, or jumping to strict policies too quickly. Always start with p=none and monitor reports before enforcement.

Question 15

How often should I review DMARC reports?

Accepted Answer

During initial implementation, review reports daily. Once stable, weekly reviews are sufficient for most organizations. Set up automated parsing tools for large volumes, and always investigate sudden changes in authentication patterns.

Question 16

What does 'pct' mean in DMARC policies?

Accepted Answer

The 'pct' tag specifies the percentage of failing messages to apply the policy to. For example, pct=25 means only 25% of failing messages will be quarantined or rejected. This allows gradual enforcement during rollout.

Question 17

Should I use strict or relaxed alignment?

Accepted Answer

Start with relaxed alignment (aspf=r, adkim=r) which allows subdomains to pass authentication. Move to strict alignment only after ensuring all legitimate email sources use the exact organizational domain in authentication.

Question 18

What happens to forwarded emails with DMARC?

Accepted Answer

Email forwarding often breaks DMARC authentication because forwarding servers modify messages and send from different IPs. This is a known limitation. Some forwarders implement ARC (Authenticated Received Chain) to preserve authentication results.

Question 19

How long does DNS propagation take for DMARC records?

Accepted Answer

DNS propagation typically takes 24-48 hours globally, but can be faster (15 minutes to a few hours) depending on TTL settings. Use DNS checker tools to verify propagation across different geographic locations before expecting full functionality.

Question 20

Can I have multiple DMARC records for one domain?

Accepted Answer

No, you can only have one DMARC record per domain. Multiple records will cause DNS resolution failures. If you need different policies for subdomains, create separate DMARC records for each subdomain (e.g., _dmarc.mail.example.com).

Question 21

What's the maximum length for DMARC record values?

Accepted Answer

DMARC records are DNS TXT records with a 255-character limit per string. Complex policies with multiple reporting addresses might need to be split across multiple strings within the same TXT record, though most policies fit comfortably within this limit.

Question 22

How do I test DMARC without affecting production email?

Accepted Answer

Start with p=none to monitor without enforcement, use a test subdomain for initial testing, send test emails to Gmail/Yahoo to check authentication headers, and use online DMARC testing tools to validate your configuration before going live.

Question 23

What should I do if legitimate emails are being rejected?

Accepted Answer

Immediately review DMARC reports to identify the source, check if the sender has proper SPF/DKIM setup, temporarily lower the policy or percentage if needed, and work with the legitimate sender to fix their authentication setup.

Question 24

Do all email providers support DMARC?

Accepted Answer

Major providers (Gmail, Yahoo, Outlook, Apple) fully support DMARC. Smaller providers may have varying levels of support. DMARC adoption is widespread but not universal, so some emails may not be subject to DMARC checks.

Question 25

How do I handle DMARC for domains that don't send email?

Accepted Answer

For non-sending domains, publish a reject policy to prevent spoofing: 'v=DMARC1; p=reject; sp=reject; adkim=s; aspf=s'. This provides maximum protection against domain spoofing since no legitimate email should come from these domains.

Free DMARC Record Generator

Why Use Our DMARC Generator?

Error-Free Syntax

Best Practice Defaults

Instant Generation

Guidance Included

Understanding DMARC Record Values

Example DMARC Record:

Version

Possible Values:

Policy

Possible Values:

Aggregate Reports URI

Possible Values:

Failure Reports URI

Possible Values:

Failure Options

Possible Values:

DKIM Alignment

Possible Values:

SPF Alignment

Possible Values:

Percentage

Possible Values:

Report Format

Possible Values:

Report Interval

Possible Values:

Subdomain Policy

Possible Values:

How to Implement Your DMARC Record

Copy the generated record

Access your DNS provider

Create TXT record

Verify publication

DMARC Troubleshooting Guide

Messages failing DMARC authentication

Symptoms:

Causes:

Solutions:

DKIM authentication failures

Symptoms:

Causes:

Solutions:

SPF authentication failures

Symptoms:

Causes:

Solutions:

Alignment issues

Symptoms:

Causes:

Solutions:

Safe DMARC Rollout Strategy

Phase 1: Preparation

Actions:

Success Criteria:

Phase 2: Monitoring

Actions:

Success Criteria:

Phase 3: Gradual Enforcement

Actions:

Success Criteria:

Phase 4: Full Protection

Actions:

Success Criteria:

Common DMARC Implementation Mistakes

Skipping the monitoring phase

Not setting up SPF and DKIM first

Using strict alignment too early

Ignoring DMARC reports

Forgetting third-party services

DMARC Generator Best Practices

Start Conservative

Use Dedicated Mailboxes

Monitor Regularly

Document Everything

DMARC Generator FAQ

Try Email Validation API for free!